When Trust Structures Erode Family Trust

Rigid structures can strain the very family harmony they are meant to protect. This author hopes to explain how that can happen, and why it is so important for families to build trust whilst everyone is still here.

A couple in their fifties sits across the table from us. They have two children in their twenties. Both are working, and one has recently married.

Near the end of our initial wealth planning process, the father says something we hear often. “We trust Providend. We hope our children will trust you too someday.”

Later, as we move into their estate planning, the conversation turns to the trust structure they want to set up. They would like distributions only at certain ages, with capital released only for approved purposes. They want clauses to keep the money away from a son-in-law who might become a former son-in-law, and a trustee with considerable discretion and the ability to say no.

I think about this a lot. Will their children one day trust us, the people who helped put such a structure in place? Or will they see us as people with a stake in keeping their inheritance locked up?

Who a Trust Structure Is Really Between

A trust is a legal arrangement set up by the settlor and administered by the trustee. In effect, the settlor is placing trust in someone, an individual or a company, to carry out their wishes for a pool of assets.

The beneficiaries have rights under it, of course, but no say in how it was written. In a family trust, the beneficiaries are usually the children. They often do not know why the terms were chosen.

Parents can explain their thinking in a letter of wishes, or a parting letter to their children, and a heartfelt one can mean a great deal. But a letter works best when it is the last word in a conversation that started while the parent is still around. On its own, it explains a decision that has already been made.

Bringing the children into that conversation gives them a voice in the decision, even though the settlor still writes the terms. However, the conversation will not change the message the terms themselves carry. A clause that holds back most of the capital until a child is well into their thirties or makes every large expense subject to a trustee’s approval, still says “we are not sure you can handle this.” No letter or conversation fully softens that, and so a structure meant as care is often received as a verdict.

What the Structure Says to Your Children

Picture the family five years on. The trust releases capital in stages: a small first tranche at 25, a larger one at 30 and the rest at 35. The son, now 28, has received his first tranche, but it does not go far. He wants help with the downpayment on his first home, so he applies to a trustee he has met only once or twice. While the parents are alive, the trustee may yet check with them before saying yes, so in effect he is asking his parents through a stranger.

His sister, at 31, has received two tranches, but anything larger still goes through the same process. Because she is married, whatever the trust pays for, such as a home, is held by the trustee rather than put in her name. Both are capable adults with careers of their own.

The most sensitive version of this is protection against a future divorce. The worry behind it is understandable, since many parents have seen marriages end badly and do not want the family’s wealth to leave with a former spouse. But consider how the child hears it: less “we do not trust your partner” and more “we do not trust your judgement in choosing one.”

If the marriage lasts, the child may spend decades wondering why the safeguard was needed. If it ends, the safeguard confirms what the parents feared all along, and either way the child remembers who put it there. In guarding against a divorce that may never happen, parents can strain a relationship with their child that exists today.

The children are unlikely to see the trustee, or the adviser who sat with their parents, as people on their side, and more likely to see us as part of the structure that says no on their parents’ behalf. It is hard to become their trusted adviser while also standing between them and their inheritance.

Serving the Goal Behind the Instruction

Some will ask whether it is our place to raise any of this. The parents are our clients, and they know their children far better than we do.

They certainly do, but our role as fee-only advisers has never been to carry out every instruction without question. If a client wanted to put their whole portfolio into one speculative stock, we would ask what they are trying to achieve and show them how this choice works against it.

Estate planning deserves the same care, and when we ask parents what they want most for their family, the answers are rarely about control. They want children who get along with each other, who handle money responsibly, and who remember them with gratitude. A structure that breeds resentment or restricts agency works against those hopes. Pointing this out, gently and early, is part of serving them well.

When Control Is the Right Answer

Restrictions are not always the wrong answer, though. In some situations, a protective structure is the most caring thing a parent can put in place.

  • Young children, who cannot yet manage money or make decisions for themselves.
  • A child with special needs, or a vulnerability that calls for care over a lifetime.
  • An adult child whose circumstances, such as an addiction, put a large sum of money and, more importantly, their life and health at real risk.

Some parents come to this later in life. They realise they never had the chance to build this kind of trust with their children. Perhaps their children were never shown how the family’s money works, or given real responsibility, or the freedom to learn from small mistakes. Perhaps the relationship is not as close as they had hoped. In that situation, a restrictive trust can be a sensible choice.

It helps to be honest with ourselves, though. A restrictive trust can ease worries about that distance, but it does not close it, even when it is framed as protection. And it is rarely too late to build trust, even with adult children. So, it is usually better as a fallback than as the first thing we reach for.

Building Trust While You Are Still Here

The better path starts earlier, and it starts with the family rather than the paperwork. The more trust parents build with their children while they are alive, the less the structure has to do in their place. Real trust between generations is built the way most trust is built: you give someone responsibility and watch how they handle it. You trust them with an opportunity to earn more trust.

In practice, that can mean:

  • Bringing adult children into conversations about the family’s money.
  • Giving them a meaningful sum to manage, and letting them make mistakes while the stakes are still small.
  • Sharing the values you hope will guide and serve them, both in what you say and in how you live.
  • Discussing the structure you are considering, and the reasons behind it, before it is finalised. These conversations often show how much of it is really needed.

Our estate planning is designed to make room for this, which is why it begins with deep discovery rather than documents. Before any lawyer drafts a clause or any trustee is appointed, we spend time understanding what the family hopes for and how its members relate to one another. Only then do we work with law firms and corporate trustees to put the structure in place. The whole process can take anywhere from six months to two years.

That can feel slow, but it leaves room for the conversations no document can have. Guiding families through them well is a skill in its own right, and one we are investing in across our advisory team.

These conversations are also a natural time for parents to introduce us to their children. It gives the children someone they can ask about the plan, and someone who can help keep the family’s conversation going long after the documents are signed.

Where the Trust Goes

A trust can protect a family’s wealth for generations, but it cannot build trust within the family. Only parents and children can do that, and only while everyone is still here.

And it helps to have those family conversations in the right context, guided by a trusted adviser.

The family described in this article is a composite, drawn from many conversations we have had with clients.

This is an original article written by Bryan Chan, Lead of Solutions at Providend, the first fee-only wealth advisory firm in Southeast Asia and a leading wealth advisory firm in Asia.

For more related resources, check out:
1. A Father’s Journey Through Legacy Planning for a Child with Special Needs
2. Leaving a Lasting Legacy: How to Make an Impact That Outlives You
3. Silent Risks in Legacy Planning: Divorce, Bankruptcy & Beneficiary Issues


Through deep conversations with our advisers, you will gain clarity on what matters most in life and what needs to be done to live a good life, both financially and non-financially. Learn more about our investment philosophy here.

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt